Barbara's Reviews > Moloka'i
Moloka'i (Moloka'i, #1)
by
by
When I think of Hawaii I think of breathtaking landscapes and pleasantly warm temperatures, not its history of Hansen's disease, better known as leprosy. I had little knowledge of the disease before reading this book. My fond memories of this beautiful state, the desire to learn more about leprosy, and all the positive reviews piqued my interest and were instrumental in my decision to read this.
Alan Brennert did a fine job researching this tragic blemish in Hawaii's history. Being quarantined by COVID19 can't be nearly as bad as being quarantined on the remote (although beautiful) island of Kalaupapa in the leper colony of Molokai. Through the words and actions of the main characters we learn about the progression of the disease, the coping mechanisms of those afflicted, as well as the courage, strength, and fear of the inhabitants.
I enjoyed this book but didn't love it. I certainly understand why so many readers rated it 5 stars. I love historical fiction and I love learning something new, especially when it motivates me to further research the topic as this book did. I'm not sure if it is my somber mood during this bizarre time period or some element missing in Brennert's writing but I'm sorry to say I didn't enjoy this enough to read the sequel.
Alan Brennert did a fine job researching this tragic blemish in Hawaii's history. Being quarantined by COVID19 can't be nearly as bad as being quarantined on the remote (although beautiful) island of Kalaupapa in the leper colony of Molokai. Through the words and actions of the main characters we learn about the progression of the disease, the coping mechanisms of those afflicted, as well as the courage, strength, and fear of the inhabitants.
I enjoyed this book but didn't love it. I certainly understand why so many readers rated it 5 stars. I love historical fiction and I love learning something new, especially when it motivates me to further research the topic as this book did. I'm not sure if it is my somber mood during this bizarre time period or some element missing in Brennert's writing but I'm sorry to say I didn't enjoy this enough to read the sequel.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Moloka'i.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 26, 2020
–
Started Reading
March 26, 2020
– Shelved
April 3, 2020
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Richard (on hiatus)
(new)
-
added it
Apr 03, 2020 10:31AM
An interesting setting ........ sounds a little like The Island, by Victoria Hislop - a really good write up Barbara and I think the all pervasive, unsettling mood at the moment does affect how we view books.
reply
|
flag
Richard wrote: "An interesting setting ........ sounds a little like The Island, by Victoria Hislop - a really good write up Barbara and I think the all pervasive, unsettling mood at the moment does affect how we ..."
I agree with you, Richard. Have you read the Hisop book? Thanks for your comment.
I agree with you, Richard. Have you read the Hisop book? Thanks for your comment.
Barbara wrote: "Richard wrote: "An interesting setting ........ sounds a little like The Island, by Victoria Hislop - a really good write up Barbara and I think the all pervasive, unsettling mood at the moment doe..."
I did read The Island and really enjoyed it, her first big hit.
I quite enjoyed her second novel set in the spanish civil war, if I remember, but according to my wife, her books go down hill a bit after that. Maybe too many books, too fast.
I did read The Island and really enjoyed it, her first big hit.
I quite enjoyed her second novel set in the spanish civil war, if I remember, but according to my wife, her books go down hill a bit after that. Maybe too many books, too fast.
I have never read any of her books. I always enjoy finding an author previously unknown to me. Thanks for getting back, Richard.
This books does sound interesting .. it may be this particular time that didn't allow you to enjoy the novel more .. Great review, Barbara :))
Beata wrote: "This books does sound interesting .. it may be this particular time that didn't allow you to enjoy the novel more .. Great review, Barbara :))"
Thanks so much for your comment, Beata. It is difficult not to have this unusual time not affect everything you read or do.
Thanks so much for your comment, Beata. It is difficult not to have this unusual time not affect everything you read or do.
Such a beautiful cover for a somber story. You've given a wonderfully thoughtful review, Barbara!😊 Timing can make all the difference.
Kimber wrote: "Such a beautiful cover for a somber story. You've given a wonderfully thoughtful review, Barbara!😊 Timing can make all the difference."
You are so right about timing. I really appreciate your comment, Kimber.
You are so right about timing. I really appreciate your comment, Kimber.
Have you looked for a NF book about this, Barbara? It's something I knew nothing about either... which of course arouses my interest!